|
You are only seeing a fraction of my work. If you want to see it all join my Patreon page at https://www.patreon.com/itsmetoo If you are already a supporter, go to the Table Of Contents on my Patreon and click the proper link to get the new password. |
Captioned Images Series: I'm Mrs. Pangborn, Now 3
Created: 06/19/2026
Nicholle stared at the text message for several seconds before reading it again.
Nicholle, please come to Mrs. Pangborn's house. I need to talk to you. — Jeffrey
She hadn't seen her brother in over a month.
At first she had assumed he was traveling or dealing with whatever new project had captured his attention. Jeffrey had always been somewhat restless. He would disappear for weeks and then suddenly reappear with stories about what he had been doing.
Still, a month was a long time.
And asking her to meet him at Mrs. Pangborn's house was strange.
Mrs. Bonnie Pangborn lived only a few blocks away. She was a woman in her fifties who had lived in the neighborhood for years.
Curious and a little concerned, Nicholle walked over that afternoon.
She rang the bell.
A familiar deepvoice called from inside.
"Come in!"
Nicholle opened the door and stepped into the living room.
Mrs. Pangborn sat in a club chair near the window.
She wore a vibrant floral-print blouse tucked into a pinstripe pencil skirt. Sheer tights covered her legs, and black Mary Jane pumps rested neatly on the carpet. Small gold earrings and a necklace completed the polished look.
Everything about her appearance seemed perfectly normal.
"Where's my brother?" Nicholle asked.
Mrs. Pangborn looked up.
"I'm Jeffrey."
Nicholle sighed immediately.
"Oh no."
"Please hear me out."
"No."
"I'm serious."
Nicholle crossed her arms.
Mrs. Pangborn took a deep breath.
"Or at least I was Jeffrey."
The sentence hung in the air.
Nicholle almost laughed.
Inst/ead she sat down across from her.
"Fine. Explain."
Mrs. Pangborn told a bizarre story.
She claimed that somehow she and Jeffrey had exchanged identities over a month ago. Everyone now recognized her as Mrs. Pangborn. Jeffrey's old life had vanished from the world.
According to her, she had spent the past month trying desperately to reverse what had happened.
"And now?" Nicholle asked.
"I found a way."
Nicholle leaned forward.
"Then why are you still Mrs. Pangborn?"
Mrs. Pangborn smiled sadly.
"Because I've decided not to use it."
Nicholle stared.
The woman continued.
At first Nicholle dismissed everything she said.
Then Mrs. Pangborn began recounting memories.
Private memories.
Stories from childhood.
Conversations that had taken place years ago.
Embarrassing incidents that only Jeffrey could possibly know.
One after another.
By the time she finished, Nicholle's certainty had begun to crack.
"How do you know all that?"
"Because I lived it."
Nicholle looked at her carefully.
Really carefully.
For the first time she tried to ignore the name that automatically came to mind whenever she saw her.
Mrs. Pangborn.
Mrs. Pangborn.
Mrs. Pangborn.
Yet the more she studied her, the stranger things became.
Mrs. Pangborn didn't actually look like a woman in her fifties.
Her face was strong and angular.
There were almost no wrinkles.
No laugh lines.
Her shoulders were broad beneath the floral blouse.
Her figure lacked the curves Nicholle subconsciously expected.
In another context, those features might easily belong to a young man.
And yet every time Nicholle looked at her, the identity attached itself instantly.
Mrs. Pangborn.
Neighbor.
Wife.
Mother.
Community volunteer.
It felt impossible to separate the appearance from the identity.
Finally Nicholle asked the question that mattered most.
"When are you becoming yourself again?"
A look of sadness crossed Mrs. Pangborn's face.
"I'm not."
"What?"
"I'm staying like this."
Nicholle blinked.
"You just said you found a way."
"I did."
"Then use it!"
Mrs. Pangborn slowly shook her head.
"You don't understand."
She looked around the room.
"My husband and I have been married for over thirty years."
Nicholle opened her mouth.
Then stopped.
Mrs. Pangborn continued.
"I have children."
She smiled faintly.
"I know exactly who they are. I remember raising them."
She looked toward a shelf filled with family photographs.
"I have friends I've known for ten years. Twenty years. Thirty years. Some for over forty years."
Nicholle listened in stunned silence.
"I have a career."
Mrs. Pangborn folded her hands.
"I'm president of a charity that helps people."
Her voice grew quieter.
"When I was twenty-three-year-old Jeffrey, I had no direction. No purpose. No idea what I wanted from life."
She looked down at herself.
"Now I wake up every morning knowing exactly who I am and what I'm supposed to do."
Nicholle shook her head.
"No."
"It's true."
"No, you're my brother."
Mrs. Pangborn smiled sadly.
"I was."
"You still are."
"I can't be."
"You have to come back."
Mrs. Pangborn looked genuinely heartbroken.
"Nicholle..."
Tears began forming in her eyes.
"You don't understand."
"Then make me understand."
Mrs. Pangborn took a long breath.
"The reason I asked you to come here today wasn't because I wanted help."
Nicholle felt her stomach tighten.
"It wasn't?"
"No."
Mrs. Pangborn's voice trembled.
"I asked you to come because I wanted to say goodbye."
The room suddenly felt very quiet.
Nicholle stared at her.
"What do you mean?"
Mrs. Pangborn looked directly at her.
"Jeffrey is never coming back."
The words hit harder than Nicholle expected.
She wanted to argue.
To insist this was madness.
To demand that her brother stop pretending.
But she couldn't.
Because the woman sitting across from her wasn't pretending.
She truly believed every word.
And somehow, impossibly, part of Nicholle believed her too.
"I'm sorry," Mrs. Pangborn whispered.
Nicholle sat silently for several minutes.
Finally she stood.
Neither of them knew what else to say.
Mrs. Pangborn walked her to the door.
At the threshold they hesitated.
Then they hugged.
Nicholle could feel tears in both their eyes.
"Goodbye," Mrs. Pangborn said softly.
Nicholle couldn't bring herself to answer.
She simply nodded and walked home.
---
In the weeks that followed, life continued.
Nicholle saw Mrs. Pangborn frequently.
She saw her walking hand-in-hand with her husband.
She saw her attending community events.
She saw her meeting friends for lunch.
She saw her arriving at work each morning.
She saw her organizing charity fundraisers and helping families in need.
Everywhere she went, people greeted Mrs. Pangborn warmly.
And Mrs. Pangborn greeted them back with the ease of someone who had known them her entire life.
Perhaps she had.
Each time Nicholle saw her, she felt a strange mixture of sadness and acceptance.
She still missed her brother.
But little by little, she began to understand what he had meant.
Mrs. Pangborn wasn't trapped.
She wasn't searching for a way out anymore.
She had chosen this life.
And whenever Nicholle saw her smiling with her family, laughing with old friends, or helping someone through her charity work, she couldn't deny that Mrs. Pangborn seemed genuinely happy.
Jeffrey was gone.
At least, the brother Nicholle had known was gone.
Yet somewhere within the life of Mrs. Bonnie Pangborn, she sometimes caught glimpses of him—a familiar expression, a certain laugh, a shared memory.
Those moments hurt.
But they also helped.
Because they reminded Nicholle that even if Jeffrey would never exist again, he hadn't disappeared entirely.
He had simply become someone else.
Image made with Gemini AI Image Generator